Kokomo bar owner Dan Dumoulin II was vindicated by the Indiana Court of Appeals Monday after a three-year battle to keep a southside strip club open and serving liquor.
Three appeals judges have unanimously ruled in Dumoulin’s favor, in a decision which could mark the end of a local remonstratrance against Dumoulin’s Ultimate Place 2B night club.
The decision, filed Sept. 30, concurs with an earlier trial court decision in the case issued by Miami County Special Judge Rosemary Higgins Burke.
In upholding Burke’s December 2007 ruling, the appeals court said Dumoulin’s liquor license renewal request was rejected in an “arbitrary and capricious manner.”
The latest ruling in the case contends the Indiana Alcohol & Tobacco Commission had insufficient evidence to, in effect, revoke Dumoulin’s liquor license at the Ultimate Place 2B, 5126 Clinton Drive.
The court of appeals ruling was a blow to local remonstrators, led by two pastors at Crossroads Community Church.
The pastors, Kevin Smith and Jeff Harlow, reluctantly gave up a previous remonstrance against the Dumoulin family after receiving certain assurances in 2001.
While Smith, Harlow and the other remonstrators may have considered those assurances — offered in writing by Dan Dumoulin II’s parents — binding, the court of appeals disagreed.
Instead, the judges last week ruled Dumoulin II was never a party to any agreement his parents made with the remonstrators.
The 2001 agreement, the judges said, was that Hoosier LLC, the corporation owned by Joan and Dan Dumoulin Sr., would not turn what opened as a sports bar into a strip club.
Arguments still rage as to whether Joan and Dan Sr. honored the second part of the agreement. In 2001, they promised that remonstrators would be notified if Hoosier LLC ever sought to transfer the liquor license.
Dan Dumoulin II’s parents transferred the license to their son in mid-2005, and the appeals court judges ruled the Dumoulins did, in fact, give sufficient notice.
The ruling notes that Kokomo attorney Mark McCann, who in 2001 had represented the remonstrators, acknowledged receiving oral notice of the pending liquor license transfer from fellow Kokomo attorney Dick Russell, prior to the transfer request being heard by the Howard County Alcoholic Beverage Board.
The remonstrators insisted the agreement was that the notification would be in writing. The appeals court was, however, satisfied that proper notice had been served, “albeit oral rather than written.”
The appeals court, like Burke, also rejected claims Joan and Dan Sr. never made a “bona fide” sale of the club to their son. An ATC hearing judge had originally ruled no paperwork existed to support the Dumoulins’ claims the club was actually sold.
That point was important to the remonstrators, who tried to claim the Dumoulins — Joan, Dan Sr. and Dan II — had always intended to operate the Ultimate as a strip club, but had been temporarily thwarted by the 2001 remonstrance.
Local News
Ultimate Place wins court battle
Three-year fight may have reached final conclusion
- Local News
-
-
Delphi retirees continue fight for pensions
A group of then-Delphi Corp. retirees saw a long road ahead of them when they banded in 2009 to keep hold of their full pensions and benefits.
-
Eastern moves ahead on wind turbine
A packed room of remonstrators Tuesday held little sway over the Eastern Howard Schools board, which voted unanimously to move ahead on a $2.75 million wind turbine project.
-
Board: discipline not strict enough
The Medical Licensing Board of Indiana has rejected a proposed resolution to a Russiaville doctor’s disciplinary case, directing the Indiana Attorney General’s Office to propose a more stringent set of requirements.
-
City to end agreement with Novia
City officials said Tuesday they’re planning to switch providers at the city’s employee health-care clinic this spring, ending a year-old relationship with Novia Health Care.
-
Eastern celebrates graduation rate improvement
The latest graduation rates prove all Howard County schools are offering a quality education, a local superintendent said.
That’s how Tracy Caddell, superintendent of the Eastern Howard School Corp., summed up the figures released Tuesday by the Indiana Department of Education.
-
Jail full of females
In late January, cell mates Monica Clark Davis and Christy Miller were awaiting disposition of their respective cases in the Howard County jail.
-
Eastern set for wind turbine meeting
GREENTOWN — Eastern Howard Schools superintendent Tracy Caddell said Monday the school board is considering alternate sites for a proposed wind turbine project, which would build a 287-foot-tall windmill to produce energy for the schools.
-
Chamber cancels cook-off
After an 11-year run, the annual chili cook-off in Kokomo has been canceled for this year.
-
Miami County GOP fails to appoint new trustee
PERU – Miami County commissioners will be forced to appoint a Perry Township trustee after the GOP’s county chairman exceeded the deadline to replace the vacated seat.
-
Students petition to keep daycare at IUK
A group of Indiana University Kokomo students is petitioning the university to reconsider shutting down an on-campus childcare center.
- More Local News Headlines
-
Former Komen Exec Defends Funding Cut
Skip the Coffee Cup and Inhale Your Caffeine Fix
Calif. Gay Marriage Ban Ruled Unconstitutional
Jury Selection for Ex-UVa Athlete Enters 2nd Day
Raw Video: Giants Celebrate Another Super Bowl
Cab Driver Helps Wis. Family Escape House Fire
Greek Leaders Seek Deal As Bankruptcy Looms
Bernanke: Recovery Depends on Consumer Spending
Staff Removed at LA School During Abuse Probe
Eastwood in Super Bowl Ad 'Compassionate'
Stranded Fishermen Rescued From Bay of Green Bay
Analyst: Outside Troops Won't Intervene in Syria
Police: Father Planned Deadly Fire for Some Time
US, UK Pressure on Syria; More Homs Violence
Raw Video: Mass Killer Wants Medal, Freedom
Court Strips Contador of Tour De France Title
Runaway Goat Leads Police on Wild Chase
And the Winner for Best Super Bowl Ad Is...
Romney Latest Poll to Join Let-me-explain Club
