When courts get involved

Opinion

Discussion

June 10, 2009

Anonymous The Kokomo Tribune Wed Jun 10, 2009, 05:00 PM EDT

A 13-year-old cancer patient underwent chemotherapy in Minnesota last month in spite of his family’s objections.

The young man’s parents said they were supporting their son’s decision to refuse medical treatment for religious reasons. They had said they would give chemotherapy a try, but they stopped after a single treatment when the chemicals made the boy sick.

Courts have been consistent in their rulings regarding the rights of children to medical care. Judges have ruled that even though adults might have the right to refuse such care on religious grounds, they do not have the right to deny that care to their children.

The California Supreme Court, for example, ruled that a mother could be prosecuted for involuntary manslaughter when her child died of meningitis. She had sought to heal the child through prayer, but prosecutors argued she should have sought medical treatment. The court made the ruling even though California law specifically exempts treatment by spiritual means from the definition of child neglect.

In the Minnesota case, the teenager’s mother took her son on a cross-country journey in an effort to protect him from a medical procedure she did not believe would make him well. She came home after her husband issued a public appeal and authorities promised she would face no criminal charges.

Physicians say the boy has a 90 percent chance of survival with chemotherapy. Without it, they say, his chances would have been 5 percent.

Perhaps most of us agree with the judges in finding that the parents in these cases are wrong. Children are too young to decide for themselves, and they should not be allowed to die simply because their parents are too stubborn to allow medical science to work its wonders.

It’s a compelling argument.

Placing ourselves in the shoes of these parents, we might have chosen differently. Perhaps we would throw everything we could find at the disease. Trying both prayer and medical science, both the traditional and the experimental.

Still, we are left to ponder how we would react if the roles here were reversed. What if the folks who question medical science were in the majority? Would we be willing to have their judgment imposed on us?

– Pharos-Tribune, Logansport, and Kokomo Tribune

Text Only | Photo Reprints

Opinion

Forever thankful
Monday is Memorial Day, a national holiday to remember those who have died while serving our country.

Memorial Day officially

May 26, 2012
Cheers and Jeers - Saturday, May 26, 2012
Thanks for your kindness

Terry Siegrist, a paralegal in Salina, Kan., sends this Cheer:

“The family of the late Esther Sprinkle wishes to send our heartfelt thanks to all who gave so generously of their kindness and sympathy in the death of our beloved mother and grandmother. We especially want to thank those who visited us at the funeral home and sent flowers, cards, memorials or food.

May 25, 2012
USPS scales back plans
The issue: Postal Service plans to keep smaller post offices open.

Our view: Agency deserves credit for listening to the concerns of customers.

May 25, 2012
Sign change is overdue
A colleague of ours years ago said Indiana lawmakers should change the state motto to “We’ll Get Around to It.” His observation is both funny and sad.

May 23, 2012 1 Story
Tips on flag etiquette
Monday is Memorial Day – set aside to honor those Americans who gave their lives in this nation’s wars. Lots of folks fly the flag every day as a show of patriotism, but what many might not know is that there are specific rules outlined in the U.S. Flag Code concerning its display.

May 21, 2012
Cheers & Jeers - Saturday, May 19, 2012
Carriers collect 19 tons of food

Brian S. Kidwell of Branch 533 of the letter carriers union sends this Cheer:

May 19, 2012
Walk a lap, fight cancer
Before you read any farther, stop for a second and think about what this one word means to you: cancer.

May 18, 2012
Program eyes troubled kids
If you know a teenager who has gotten off track, Elissa Andersen might be just the person to call.

May 16, 2012
Editorial - May 15, 2012: Hard work still pays
The issue: The Class of 2012.

Our view: Congratulations on your achievement, graduating high school seniors, and remember to thank those who helped you along the way to success.

May 15, 2012
de la Bastide: Indiana, the nation lose true statesman
During his 36 years in the U.S. Senate, Richard Lugar was noted for his ability to compro-mise when it came to legislation impacting the nation, and as a statesman when it came to foreign policy issues.

May 15, 2012
More Opinion Headlines

Opinion

Search Results

Discussion

When courts get involved

Site Map

Contact Us